A popular discussion platform showcases media pitches gone awry, with a stern eye on the PR industry. A few quick clicks reveal blog headlines that call publicists arrogant, begging them to “suck less” and “stop being bad at stuff” amongst other things. While our side gets thrown a bone here and there, for the most part we get ridiculed quite mercilessly.
Of course, when publicists do something monumentally clumsy or deceitful, we deserve criticism, it’s a good way for us to improve. Still, publicists sometimes deal with reporters who don’t seem to get that we’re all in this beautiful mess together.
Dear reporters, before you think a publicist’s only goal is to raise your blood pressure, please know the following:
• Reporters help us accomplish our goals, but please remember we help you with your jobs too. You know who writes the online bios about your interview subject, who feeds you key facts and figures about the industry you cover, who gets you that sought-after intel no one else seems to know? Publicists do. We realize a key headline or fantastic placement depends on willing reporters, but we are a fundamental part of the process too – please, please, please don’t forget that.
• We are not encyclopedias. The press secretary can’t be expected to rattle off every single vote a Senator ever cast; the media relations VP can’t be expected to recall the location of all 73 global offices; the intern will never know when the client’s product will launch. When we don’t have answers, we usually ask around or go online to find out – just like you. If you want, we will dig around and get back to you. Not everyone passes (or likes) pop quizzes.
• We too deal with tyrannical, delusional bosses and soul-crushing demands on our time. There are many kind, thoughtful and driven people in PR who mentor junior staff and challenge them to do their best. And, there are many work environments that encourage respect, teamwork and creativity. But for every caring boss, there are lowlifes who berate, demean and insult their workers. For every awesome office, there are firms with exorbitant billing requirements, pointless expectations of face time and “colleagues” who sabotage and steal your work. Buy us a beer, we’d be happy to trade war stories.
• Our jobs are also in jeopardy. As publicists, we sympathize with the fact that the media industry is in an distressing, ongoing state of upheaval. But know that as newspapers shutter and reporters get pink-slipped, PR firms are hemorrhaging talent at a rapid clip. You’re not the only one wondering if that next phone call or email is HR asking us to “stop by for a friendly chat about your future.”
• It all comes full circle, baby. Good for you if you aim to be the next Cronkite; the world needs smart, demanding, no-nonsense reporters who deliver balanced and thought-provoking feedback. But, some of you may want to join our line of work eventually, to get a taste of the alleged dark other side. If so, you may want to think twice the next time you’re tempted to sneer at a publicist if you’re not getting the answers you want. Thanks to social networks, endless happy hours and meet-and-greets, the publicist community is more tight-knit than you may think. Know that gossip about a reporter’s bullish treatment and imbalanced coverage gets around very quickly.
[...] reporters and make them understand its not so easy for us. This morning, I came upon this post, FIVE THINGS EVERY PUBLICIST WANTS THE MEDIA TO UNDERSTAND and it made me feel a little [...]
[...] world outside of our JMC classes that we will continue to have to overcome. In an entry posted on The Blog Aesthetic, it spells out five things every publicist wants the media to know, and I couldn’t agree more. [...]
As a former journalist who received lots of BAD media releases and phone calls from PR people (and who now trains people how to write media releases and how to deal with media people), I feel compelled to comment. Your first point is totally valid – journalists do rely on PR people for lots of good stories. But as for the rest of your points, sorry, it’s not a journalist’s responsibility to care about those things -they’re irrelevant. Journalists want PR people to understand the rules of the game: send the right, newsworthy information to the right people at the right time. And please please please, cut the PR fluff (even if your clients want you to include it in a media release).
Nodding away reading this. Fifth point is more real than you think =)
Kay raised a good point, journalists don’t care. What we can do is be a better PR and think of better ways to consult, advice, or threaten the clients to do things the right way =)
- Seet
Greetings from Kuala Lumpur